Involuntary Mediumship and Clairvoyance: Max Heindel, Charlatanism, and Fraud in Psychic Phenomena — How to Distinguish Genuine Experiences from Fraudulent Manifestations
Involuntary Mediumship and Clairvoyance: Max Heindel, Charlatanism, and Fraud in Psychic Phenomena — How to Distinguish Genuine Experiences from Fraudulent Manifestations
By R.V. Garcia
Revista & Escolas de Mistérios | Multidisciplinary Encyclopedia
Introduction — The Boundary Between Involuntary Perception, Conscious Clairvoyance, and Charlatanism
In 1909, writer and Western esoteric thinker Max Heindel published The Rosicrucian Cosmo-Conception, a work presenting an extensive interpretation of the spiritual constitution of human beings, the evolution of consciousness, the invisible worlds, and the possibility of developing higher perceptual faculties.
Among the subjects addressed by Heindel is a particularly interesting discussion for the history of Spiritualism and the investigation of psychic phenomena: the distinction between the involuntary medium, the involuntary clairvoyant, and the individual who, according to his teachings, has consciously developed the ability to perceive spiritual realities.
Heindel proposes that certain individuals may experience spontaneous perceptions, images, or impressions that are not subject to conscious control. According to his interpretation, these experiences may occur intermittently, appearing under certain circumstances and disappearing under others.
In contemporary terms, we might describe this discussion as an attempt to distinguish spontaneous subjective experiences, claims of extrasensory perception, and abilities that certain esoteric traditions regard as capable of being developed through conscious training.
However, the most striking aspect of Heindel's discussion is not simply his spiritual interpretation of these phenomena. It is his warning about the possibility of fraud.
He observes that some mediums, when unable to produce the information expected by their clients, may resort to inventing answers in order to preserve the appearance of possessing special abilities, satisfy those seeking their services, and continue receiving payment.
His observation is remarkably direct: the existence of people who claim to possess extraordinary perceptual abilities does not automatically make all of them fraudsters. At the same time, such claims should never be accepted without scrutiny.
Heindel draws attention to a question that remains relevant today: how do we distinguish someone who sincerely believes they possess an extraordinary faculty from someone who deliberately fabricates information for financial gain?
This distinction is essential to any serious investigation.
A subjective experience may be sincere without its interpretation necessarily being correct. A claim of extrasensory perception may deserve investigation without its authenticity having been established. And a manifestation deliberately manufactured through conscious manipulation may constitute fraud.
These three situations must not be confused.
Another interesting aspect of Heindel's work is his association of spiritual perception with the pituitary body and the pineal gland, to which he assigns an esoteric significance related to the development of higher perceptual faculties.
Within the Rosicrucian cosmology presented by the author, these structures are associated with the awakening of a form of perception that would allow human beings to establish conscious contact with what he calls the inner worlds.
Naturally, this interpretation belongs to Heindel's esoteric system. Contemporary medicine and neuroscience do not recognize the pineal gland or the pituitary gland as instruments of clairvoyance or communication with spiritual dimensions.
Throughout this study, we will maintain a clear distinction between esoteric interpretations and established scientific knowledge.
Our purpose is neither to defend mediumship indiscriminately nor to condemn everyone who reports psychic experiences. Instead, we seek to examine different historical, philosophical, and investigative perspectives, exploring how concerns about the authenticity of psychic phenomena and the exploitation of human credulity developed over time.
To accomplish this, we will draw upon authors and investigators from different periods, ranging from classical antiquity to researchers of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
Before proceeding, we present the passage from Max Heindel's work that inspired this investigation.
1. Max Heindel — The Pituitary Body and the Pineal Gland: Involuntary Mediumship and Fraud
Work: The Rosicrucian Cosmo-Conception
Chapter XVII: The Method of Acquiring First-Hand Knowledge
Section: The Pituitary Body and the Pineal Gland
Original publication: 1909
Working translation from the original English text, preserving the sequence of the author's argument.
The Pituitary Body and the Pineal Gland
In the brain, approximately in the positions shown in Diagram 17, are two small organs called the pituitary body and the pineal gland. Medical science knows little about these structures or about the other ductless glands of the body. The pineal gland is called the atrophied third eye, although neither it nor the pituitary body is actually atrophying.
This presents a puzzle to scientists, because nature retains nothing useless. Throughout the body, we find organs that are either degenerating or developing. The former may be regarded as milestones along the path humanity has traveled to reach its present stage of development, while the latter point toward possibilities for future improvement.
For example, the muscles that animals use to move their ears are also present in human beings, but because they are atrophying, few people can use them. The heart belongs to the category of organs that indicate future development, because, as previously explained by the author, it is becoming a voluntary muscle.
The pituitary body and the pineal gland belong to a third category of organs that, at present, are neither evolving nor degenerating, but remain dormant.
In a distant past, when humanity was in contact with the inner worlds, these organs served as means of access to those dimensions and, according to Heindel, would once again perform this function at a later stage of human development.
They were connected with the involuntary, or sympathetic, nervous system. At that time, human beings perceived the inner worlds, as supposedly occurred during the Lunar Period and in the later portions of the Lemurian and Atlantean Epochs. Images appeared independently of the individual's will.
The sensory centers of the desire body rotated counterclockwise, following what Heindel describes as a negative response to the Earth's rotation, in the same way that he believed the sensory centers of mediums still operated.
In most people, these sensory centers remain inactive. However, according to his system, genuine development would cause them to begin rotating clockwise. This would be the most difficult characteristic to acquire in the development of positive clairvoyance.
The development of mediumship is much easier because, in Heindel's interpretation, it represents the reawakening of a mirror-like faculty possessed by humanity in a distant past. Through this faculty, the external world was involuntarily reflected in the individual. He believed that this function had subsequently been preserved through heredity.
Among contemporary mediums, this ability is intermittent, which explains why they sometimes succeed in seeing and, at other times, fail completely for no apparent reason.
Occasionally, the intense desire of the person seeking a consultation enables the medium to obtain the information being requested. On such occasions, the medium may perceive something accurately, but not all mediums are honest.
Office rent and other expenses must be paid. Therefore, when this faculty, over which they have no conscious control, fails, some resort to fraud and say whatever comes into their minds in order to satisfy the client and receive payment. In doing so, they also discredit whatever they may genuinely have perceived on other occasions.
Anyone aspiring to genuine spiritual vision and perception must, above all, demonstrate unselfishness, because a trained clairvoyant does not experience days when the faculty simply disappears.
Such an individual is not like a mirror, dependent upon whatever reflections may happen to reach it. According to Heindel, the trained clairvoyant can direct attention toward the thoughts and plans of others at any time and in any direction, provided that the individual consciously chooses to investigate them. Otherwise, this perception is not exercised.
The great danger to society, should this power be indiscriminately used by an unworthy individual, can easily be understood. Such a person would supposedly be capable of reading the most private thoughts of others.
For this reason, Heindel states that the initiate is bound by solemn vows that prohibit the use of this power for personal advantage, even when doing so might prevent personal suffering.
An initiate might feed five thousand people, if desired, but should not turn a stone into bread merely to satisfy personal hunger.
Such an individual might heal others of paralysis and leprosy, but, according to the universal law described by Heindel, would not be permitted to stop his own mortal wounds.
Because of this commitment to absolute unselfishness, Heindel maintains that the initiate may save others but cannot save himself.
Thus, the trained clairvoyant who genuinely has something to offer would never advertise services in exchange for payment. Knowledge would be offered freely whenever considered appropriate, in accordance with the Law of Consequence.
Trained clairvoyance, according to Heindel, is the form employed in investigating occult facts and the only form genuinely useful for that purpose.
Therefore, the aspirant should not seek to satisfy idle curiosity, but should instead cultivate a sacred and unselfish desire to help humanity.
Until such a desire exists, no progress can be made toward the attainment of positive clairvoyance.
2. The Involuntary Medium and the Involuntary Clairvoyant: Heindel's Distinction
To understand Max Heindel's ideas more fully, we must also examine a passage from Chapter II, The Four Kingdoms.
In this section, the author develops a distinction between the perceptual centers of the desire body and the forms of clairvoyance that, according to his teachings, may manifest in human beings.
Heindel describes the involuntary clairvoyant as an individual whose perception is associated with a negative movement of the sensory centers. Within his interpretation, such individuals function somewhat like mirrors, reflecting whatever appears before them without being able to consciously direct their own perception.
By contrast, the properly developed voluntary clairvoyant is described as having perceptual centers that rotate in the opposite direction, allowing conscious investigation of whatever the individual chooses to examine.
The author considers this distinction fundamental to differentiating mediumship from a form of clairvoyance that has been consciously developed.
An important qualification is necessary: in Heindel's system, the terms involuntary medium and involuntary clairvoyant do not necessarily describe two entirely separate human categories. He himself associates mediumship with involuntary clairvoyance.
His classification can be summarized as follows:
Involuntary medium: An individual whose mediumistic perceptions, according to Heindel's interpretation, occur without conscious control and may manifest intermittently.
Involuntary clairvoyant: An individual whose perception is spontaneous, passive, and dependent upon whatever happens to appear within the individual's awareness.
Voluntary clairvoyant: An individual who, within the Rosicrucian framework, has developed the ability to direct perception consciously.
Trained clairvoyant: A more advanced stage of development that Heindel associates with perceptual discipline, discernment, and an altruistic commitment.
The author adds a moral warning: the claimed ability to perceive extraordinary phenomena should never be used as an instrument for personal enrichment or the exploitation of other people's curiosity.
This is one of the most interesting aspects of his work.
Nevertheless, we must distinguish Heindel's esoteric classification from a scientific one. There is no established experimental evidence demonstrating that the movements of the desire-body centers described by the author correspond to actual physiological mechanisms.
3. Ancient Philosophy and the Concern About False Diviners
Concern about deception in divinatory practices long predates the emergence of modern Spiritualism.
In different ancient civilizations, priests, oracles, dream interpreters, and diviners played important roles in religious, political, and social life.
At the same time, philosophers and intellectuals questioned the reliability of these practices, the possibility of mistaken interpretations, and the use of popular credulity for personal advantage.
Cicero — De Divinatione
First century BCE
Marcus Tullius Cicero, the Roman philosopher, orator, and statesman, wrote De Divinatione (On Divination), one of antiquity's most important philosophical works examining divinatory practices.
The work presents a dialogue between two positions: one defending the possibility of divination and another questioning the validity of different forms of prediction and the interpretation of extraordinary events.
Cicero examines dreams, omens, oracles, religious interpretations, and divinatory practices.
His contribution to our investigation lies in his concern with the rational examination of extraordinary claims.
Cicero does not offer a classification resembling Heindel's distinction between involuntary mediums and voluntary clairvoyants. His discussion belongs to a different historical and philosophical context.
Nevertheless, an important point of comparison emerges: the need to distinguish experiences considered worthy of investigation from mistaken interpretations, superstition, and deliberate manipulation.
Cicero's work demonstrates that skepticism and critical examination of divinatory claims were already important philosophical concerns more than two thousand years ago.
The Tradition of the Ancient Greek Oracles
The oracles of ancient Greece also deserve attention.
The best-known was the Oracle of Delphi, associated with the sanctuary of Apollo.
Consultations were conducted through religious procedures and interpretations attributed to a priestess known as the Pythia.
Oracular responses were often ambiguous and required interpretation.
It would be historically inaccurate to classify all ancient priests and oracles as fraudsters. These practices must be understood within the religious, cultural, and political context of their time.
What we can investigate is how spiritual authority, the interpretation of signs, and the expectation of receiving extraordinary information may create circumstances in which human credulity becomes vulnerable to manipulation.
4. Allan Kardec — Charlatanism and Deception in Mediumistic Manifestations
1861 — The Mediums' Book
Allan Kardec is an essential reference for this investigation.
In The Mediums' Book, published in 1861, Kardec devotes Part Two, Chapter XXVIII, to a subject whose title is particularly relevant to our discussion:
Charlatanism and Jugglery.
This chapter is especially important because it directly addresses self-interested mediums and fraudulent spirit manifestations.
Kardec recognizes that mediumship may be exploited commercially and that the existence of fraudulent individuals requires caution among those seeking spiritual manifestations.
However, he also makes an important qualification: the existence of fraudulent mediums does not prove that all mediums are impostors.
This distinction is fundamental to a balanced investigation.
Kardec examines the possibility that physical manifestations may be imitated by conjurers and stage performers, questions the financial interests involved, and emphasizes the importance of understanding the procedures used during séances.
In paragraph 304, he addresses self-interested mediums and the commercial exploitation of mediumistic abilities.
In the following paragraphs, he examines fraudulent spirit manifestations and the possibility of manipulating phenomena that may impress unsuspecting observers.
His discussion has a thematic similarity to Max Heindel's warning: individuals may manufacture phenomena or information in order to obtain material advantages.
Nevertheless, the two authors do not present precisely the same doctrine.
Kardec develops a classification of mediumistic faculties and a discussion of spirit manifestations, while Heindel incorporates his interpretation into a Rosicrucian cosmology involving subtle bodies and spiritual development.
Comparing these authors is particularly interesting because it demonstrates that concern about mediumistic honesty was not restricted to a single esoteric or Spiritualist school.
5. The Society for Psychical Research and the Emergence of Organized Psychic Investigation
London, 1882
In 1882, the Society for Psychical Research (SPR) was founded in London to investigate claims involving psychic phenomena.
Among the subjects examined were:
- Telepathy.
- Apparitions.
- Mediumship.
- Physical phenomena produced during séances.
- Claims concerning survival of consciousness after death.
- Alleged forms of extrasensory perception.
The establishment of the society represented a historical attempt to develop more systematic procedures for examining phenomena that had previously been discussed largely within religious, philosophical, and Spiritualist circles.
One of its important methodological concerns was the possibility of fraud, observational errors, and mistaken interpretations.
The existence of respectable witnesses was not, by itself, considered sufficient proof of an extraordinary manifestation.
Researchers needed to examine the conditions under which the phenomenon occurred, the opportunities for manipulation, and the quality of the available records.
This concern remains essential to any serious contemporary investigation.
The SPR did not establish a definitive institutional position affirming every claimed psychic phenomenon. Its history includes different interpretations, controversies, and methodological debates.
6. Eusapia Palladino — Between Alleged Manifestations and Documented Attempts at Deception
One of the most interesting cases in the history of psychical research involves Eusapia Palladino, an Italian medium who became internationally known in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
Palladino participated in numerous séances investigated by researchers, physicians, physicists, and European intellectuals.
Her reported manifestations included the movement of objects, physical effects, and phenomena interpreted by participants as manifestations of invisible intelligences.
However, her history was also marked by incidents of deception.
In 1895, during a series of séances held in Cambridge under the auspices of the Society for Psychical Research, investigators observed repeated instances of cheating.
Researchers reported circumstances in which the medium appeared to use bodily movements that were not adequately controlled by the observers to produce certain effects.
The Cambridge investigation seriously undermined the credibility of the manifestations observed under those conditions.
However, the historical record did not end there.
In 1908, a new investigation conducted in Naples by Everard Feilding, William W. Baggally, and Hereward Carrington produced a more favorable report concerning certain manifestations, under conditions the investigators regarded as more rigorous.
This demonstrates the historical complexity of the case.
It would be incorrect to use evidence of deception in particular séances as automatic proof that every phenomenon attributed to Palladino was fraudulent.
Likewise, favorable reports from certain investigators do not erase documented incidents of deception.
The case illustrates an essential principle: psychic phenomena must be evaluated individually, with attention to the specific conditions of each investigation and the evidence available.
A medium's reputation is no substitute for verification.
7. Harry Price and William Hope — Fraud in Spirit Photography
Another important episode occurred in the early twentieth century and involved British investigator Harry Price and spirit photographer William Hope.
Hope claimed to produce photographs in which images of deceased individuals appeared.
Spirit photography attracted considerable attention because it seemed to offer visual evidence of communication with the dead.
In 1922, however, Harry Price investigated the photographic procedures used by Hope and presented evidence suggesting manipulation of photographic plates.
The suspicion was that previously prepared plates were being substituted during the photographic process, producing images later presented as spiritual apparitions.
The episode became an important historical case in the investigation of fraud associated with Spiritualism.
The William Hope case demonstrates that technological developments can also provide new instruments for exploiting human credulity.
During the nineteenth century, certain manifestations were allegedly produced through physical tricks and manipulation during séances. In the twentieth century, photography became another means of creating apparently extraordinary evidence.
The investigative lesson is clear: an image, no matter how impressive, must be examined in terms of its origin, the procedure used to produce it, and the possibility of manipulation.
8. Contemporary Science and the Pineal Gland: What Is Established Knowledge and What Belongs to Esotericism?
Max Heindel's discussion of the pineal gland and the pituitary body requires scientific context.
At the beginning of the twentieth century, knowledge of the endocrine system was still developing. Contemporary neuroendocrinology has advanced considerably since then.
Today, we know that the pineal gland is a structure located in the brain whose best-established function involves the production and secretion of melatonin.
This hormone plays an important role in regulating circadian rhythms and the sleep-wake cycle.
The pituitary gland, also known as the hypophysis, performs essential endocrine functions, participating in hormonal regulation and the control of several glands and physiological processes.
The association of these structures with clairvoyance and the perception of spiritual worlds belongs to Heindel's esoteric interpretation. It is not a function recognized by contemporary medicine.
This distinction matters because multidisciplinary research must not transform philosophical or spiritual hypotheses into scientific claims without supporting evidence.
That does not prevent us from examining the symbolic significance of the pineal gland in different philosophical and religious traditions.
Throughout history, the pineal gland has received interpretations extending beyond its anatomical function. René Descartes, for example, associated it with the interaction between the soul and the body in his philosophical system.
In later esoteric traditions, the gland was also associated with the so-called third eye and spiritual perception.
These interpretations are historically significant, but they must be distinguished from physiological functions established through scientific research.
9. How Can We Distinguish Subjective Experiences, Claims of Psychic Perception, and Fraudulent Manifestations?
This is the central question of our investigation.
The existence of documented fraud does not justify concluding that everyone who reports mediumistic experiences is deliberately deceiving others.
On the other hand, a person's sincerity does not establish the authenticity of an extraordinary experience.
For a balanced investigation, we must consider at least three different situations.
First: A Sincere Subjective Experience
An individual reports perceiving an image, hearing a voice, experiencing a sensation, or receiving an impression interpreted as a spiritual manifestation.
The experience may be deeply meaningful to the person who lived through it.
However, its interpretation may involve psychological, cultural, religious, neurological, or other factors that have not yet been fully clarified.
The sincerity of a report is not equivalent to proof of its interpretation.
Second: A Claim of Extrasensory Perception
An individual claims to obtain information that could not be explained through conventional means of perception.
Such a claim must be examined using procedures designed to reduce the possibility of information leakage, suggestion, involuntary cues, and retrospective interpretation.
The more independent and controlled the investigation, the greater the opportunity to evaluate the consistency of the results.
An isolated report does not constitute scientific proof.
Third: Deliberate Fraud
Here we encounter a fundamentally different situation.
The individual knows that information is being fabricated, objects are being manipulated, images are being artificially prepared, or manifestations are being presented as spontaneous when they are not.
When there is a conscious intention to deceive in order to obtain money, prestige, or another advantage, the issue becomes one of ethical responsibility and, depending on the circumstances and applicable law, may also become a legal matter.
This is precisely the situation Max Heindel condemns when describing mediums who, unable to produce a genuine perception, resort to fabricated answers in order to satisfy their clients.
The distinction among these three situations is indispensable.
We should not turn a subjective experience into proof of spiritual communication, but neither should we automatically interpret the absence of scientific confirmation as evidence of fraud.
The most responsible approach is investigation.
10. Reflection — Honesty as the Foundation of Psychic Investigation
One issue has persisted throughout human history: the possibility of exploiting commercially what other people regard as extraordinary.
When we examine the warnings of Cicero, Allan Kardec, Max Heindel, and the investigators of the Society for Psychical Research, we find a recurring concern: the need to distinguish an allegedly extraordinary experience from the deliberate manipulation of human credulity.
Heindel makes a particularly interesting observation when he acknowledges that, within his own interpretation, involuntary perception is intermittent.
His argument is that the inability to control a particular experience should never be replaced by fabricated answers.
This issue remains entirely understandable in contemporary society.
Imagine someone consulting a supposed medium in search of information about a deceased family member. The individual providing the service claims access to information that would not ordinarily be available through conventional means.
If the medium cannot produce any information but invents answers to preserve a reputation and receive payment, the issue is no longer merely a matter of religious belief. It becomes an ethical problem involving honesty and the exploitation of another person's emotional vulnerability.
Another distinction must also be established: an individual may sincerely believe in possessing a particular faculty without that belief demonstrating that the interpretation is correct.
We must therefore avoid two equally problematic extremes.
The first is to accept every manifestation indiscriminately as proof of a spiritual reality.
The second is to reject every account in advance, treating all mediums and researchers of psychic phenomena as impostors.
Both positions prevent genuine independent investigation.
The history of psychical research demonstrates the existence of fraud, observational errors, controversies, subjective experiences, and reports that attracted the interest of researchers from different backgrounds.
The existence of these episodes does not authorize universal conclusions.
What truly matters is the quality of the evidence, the possibility of reproducing results, the transparency of procedures, and the independence of investigators.
We must also recognize that the absence of financial interest does not, by itself, prove authenticity. Someone may act without charging money and still be mistaken. Likewise, charging for a service does not automatically establish fraud.
What must be examined is the individual's conduct, the nature of the claim, the evidence presented, and whether deliberate manipulation has occurred.
In this respect, Heindel's warning carries an ethical significance that extends beyond his own cosmology.
The claim to possess an extraordinary faculty does not eliminate the obligation to be honest.
11. Conclusion — Between Experience, Belief, and Moral Responsibility
Max Heindel's warning, published in 1909, remains an interesting starting point for the historical and philosophical investigation of mediumship.
His text presents a distinction between involuntary perception and voluntary clairvoyance, assigning the latter a higher stage of spiritual development associated with conscious control and unselfishness.
At the same time, the author acknowledges the possibility of fraud among those who claim to possess mediumistic abilities.
This concern has historical parallels in different periods, from Cicero's philosophical discussions of divination to Allan Kardec's warnings about charlatanism and the investigations conducted by the Society for Psychical Research.
History demonstrates that interest in psychic phenomena has always been accompanied by controversies, contradictory testimony, subjective experiences, hypotheses, and documented instances of manipulation.
We do not need to accept every spiritual explanation in advance to recognize the historical importance of these investigations.
Likewise, we should not indiscriminately dismiss every account simply because documented fraud exists.
A genuine commitment to investigation requires a willingness to examine different possibilities, compare accounts, seek evidence, and revise conclusions when new information emerges.
There is a fundamental difference between believing that one possesses an extraordinary faculty and demonstrating that such a faculty actually exists.
And there is an even greater difference between being unable to explain a phenomenon and inventing an explanation while knowing that it is false.
Mediumship, clairvoyance, and psychic phenomena belong to a complex historical and philosophical field. They demand responsibility both from those who claim to possess extraordinary abilities and from those who undertake to investigate them.
Honesty is not a supernatural faculty. It is a human responsibility.
Bibliography and Research Sources
Max Heindel — Primary Source
HEINDEL, Max. The Rosicrucian Cosmo-Conception; or, Mystic Christianity. Oceanside, California: The Rosicrucian Fellowship, 1909.
Chapter II: The Four Kingdoms.
Chapter XVII: The Method of Acquiring First-Hand Knowledge. Section: The Pituitary Body and the Pineal Gland.
Original English edition:
https://www.rosicrucian.com/rcc/rcceng00.htm
Chapter II:
https://www.rosicrucian.com/rcc/rcceng02.htm
Chapter XVII:
https://www.rosicrucian.com/rcc/rcceng17.htm
Classical Philosophy
CICERO, Marcus Tullius. De Divinatione (On Divination). First century BCE. A philosophical dialogue examining divination, dreams, omens, and the interpretation of extraordinary events.
English text and translation:
https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Cicero/de_Divinatione/home.html
Spiritualism and Mediumship
KARDEC, Allan. The Mediums' Book. 1861. Part Two, Chapter XXVIII: Charlatanism and Jugglery. Particularly paragraphs 304–323.
English edition and searchable text:
https://www.kardecpedia.com/en/study-guide/884/the-mediums-book
Chapter XXVIII — Charlatanism and Jugglery:
https://www.kardecpedia.com/en/study-guide/884/the-mediums-book/979/part-second-spirit-manifestations/chapter-xxviii-charlatanism-and-jugglery
Historical Research into Psychic Phenomena
SOCIETY FOR PSYCHICAL RESEARCH. Institutional history. London, founded in 1882.
https://www.spr.ac.uk/about/our-history
PSI ENCYCLOPEDIA. Eusapia Palladino. Historical account of the investigations and controversies surrounding her mediumship.
https://psi-encyclopedia.spr.ac.uk/articles/eusapia-palladino/
CARRINGTON, Hereward. Eusapia Palladino and Her Phenomena. New York: Herbert B. Turner & Co., 1909.
Historical account of the 1908 Naples investigations.
Historical Investigation of Spirit Photography
SERA-SHRIAR, Efram. Photographic Plates and Spirit Fakes: Remembering Harry Price's Investigation of William Hope's Spirit Photography at Its Centenary. Science Museum Group Journal, 2022.
https://doi.org/10.15180/221707
Contemporary Scientific References
ARENDT, Josephine; AULINAS, Anna. Physiology of the Pineal Gland and Melatonin. Endotext. Updated October 30, 2022.
National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI), National Library of Medicine.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK550972/
Revista & Escolas de Mistérios
Author: R.V. Garcia
The Constant Investigation of Truth.
Documented facts, interpretations, and speculation: three categories that must remain clearly distinguished.
An independent study of a historical, philosophical, and multidisciplinary nature. Esoteric interpretations are attributed to their respective authors and should not be confused with established scientific knowledge.











Comentários
Postar um comentário
COMENTE AQUI