Humanity’s Journey Through From silent cinema to the Cold War and contemporary science fiction: a philosophical investigation into evolution, creation, enslavement, intelligence

 .

Rv Garcia




 


Humanity’s Journey Through Cinema — Mythology, Religion, Science, Power, and the Fall of the Human Being


**From silent cinema to the Cold War and contemporary science fiction: a philosophical investigation into evolution, creation, enslavement, intelligence, and the fate of civilizations.**


*By R. V. Garcia | Revista & Escolas de Mistérios — Multidisciplinary Encyclopedia*


## Introduction — Cinema Holds a Mirror to Humanity


There is a fear that transcends historical periods, cultures, and traditions: the possibility of losing what we believe makes us human without necessarily losing consciousness, memory, or the ability to understand the world. To remain alive but without freedom. To think but be unable to act. To possess intelligence yet be treated like an animal. To discover that our bodies, our species, and even our history can be subjected to the interests of a superior intelligence, a dominant civilization, or a system that sees us as nothing more than useful resources.


Cinema has transformed this fear into unforgettable images.


Across different eras, American and European filmmakers have imagined societies in which workers become components of enormous machines, human beings become food, the descendants of a civilization lose their intelligence, artificially created creatures rebel against their makers, and humanity discovers that it may not occupy the highest position in the hierarchy of existence.


These narratives did not emerge in isolation. They engage with ancient questions found in mythology, religion, philosophy, literature, science, and the historical transformation of human societies.


Who created humanity? Does existence have a purpose? Does intelligence make a species superior? Does technological progress necessarily mean moral progress? Does a more advanced civilization have the right to dominate another? And what happens when a species that considers itself superior begins treating other living beings as instruments, resources, property, or raw material?


Science fiction, horror, philosophical fantasy, and dystopian cinema have turned these questions into imaginative laboratories. Instead of presenting abstract concepts alone, these films place audiences inside worlds where the consequences of particular choices become visible.


In *Metropolis*, industrialization turns workers into components of a gigantic system. In *Island of Lost Souls*, science attempts to reshape life according to the will of a researcher. In *The Time Machine*, an apparently idyllic society conceals a monstrous division between those who live on the surface and those who dwell underground. In *2001: A Space Odyssey*, human evolution is associated with an intelligence that may lie beyond our comprehension.


Around the same historical period, *Planet of the Apes* presents a reversal of the hierarchy between humans and animals. Years later, *Soylent Green* transforms environmental collapse and food scarcity into an industrial nightmare. *The Matrix* imagines humanity imprisoned within an artificial reality, while *WALL-E* depicts a future in which comfort and automation have contributed to the erosion of human independence.


More recently, *Prometheus* revisits one of humanity’s oldest questions: What if our creators existed but had no obligation to love us, protect us, or explain our origins?


The illustrated speculative-evolution book *All Tomorrows* takes the question even further. Humanity undergoes biological transformations, genetic interventions, catastrophes, and extinctions that challenge the assumption that our species occupies a permanent place in the universe.


Taken together, these works reveal a kind of double movement. In some narratives, humanity rises: it develops tools, explores space, expands its intelligence, and seeks to understand the cosmos. In others, it descends: it loses freedom, becomes domesticated, is subjected to experiments, turns into a commodity, or survives only as the fossilized remains of a vanished civilization.


This imagery of ascent and decline can be compared, as an interpretive framework, with the philosophical ladder presented by Ramon Llull in the early fourteenth century. His work, *Liber de ascensu et descensu intellectus*, was composed in Montpellier in March 1305 and printed in Valencia in 1512. It belongs to a medieval tradition that organized reality into a hierarchy.


The purpose of this investigation, however, is not to claim that the filmmakers discussed here were directly influenced by Llull. Such a claim would require specific historical evidence. Instead, his ladder serves as a comparative metaphor—a way of examining the recurring movements of elevation, degradation, domination, and transformation found in cinematic storytelling.


The true subject of this essay is cinema as a symbolic record of humanity’s anxieties: a mirror reflecting both our dreams of transcendence and our fear of losing freedom, identity, and control over our own destiny.


## 1. The Ladder of Existence: Medieval Philosophy and Cinematic Imagination


In 1305, Ramon Llull composed *Liber de ascensu et descensu intellectus*, a title that can be translated as *The Book of the Ascent and Descent of the Intellect*. One of its best-known visual representations depicts different levels of existence: stone, flame, plant, animal, human being, heaven, angel, and God.


Within its medieval Christian framework, the image expresses a hierarchical conception of reality and the intellect’s capacity to move through different levels of knowledge. Existence is represented not merely as a collection of unrelated objects but as an ordered structure in which different forms of being occupy different positions.


The image matters to this investigation because of its symbolic power.


Modern cinema also organizes its imagined worlds into levels. Some rule while others obey; some build machines while others are consumed by them; some create a species while others become subjects of its experiments; some occupy the outer reaches of space while others remain trapped inside artificial environments.


Contemporary narratives frequently reverse the traditional hierarchy.


Human beings, who occupy a privileged place in certain religious conceptions, can become objects of exploitation by a superior intelligence. A civilization that considers itself advanced may discover that its technology cannot protect it from extinction. A species that dominates animals may imagine a future in which it is domesticated in turn.


The ladder ceases to be merely a representation of spiritual ascent and becomes a question about power.


Who determines each being’s position? Who establishes the hierarchy? What does it mean to be superior—to possess greater strength, intelligence, technology, consciousness, or moral capacity?


These criteria are not interchangeable. A society may possess extraordinary technology and remain morally primitive. An individual may possess exceptional intelligence and use it to exploit others. A civilization may master genetic engineering without fully understanding the ethical consequences of its decisions.


This is where cinema becomes philosophically revealing: it separates technological advancement from moral evolution.


Humanity can rise in knowledge while falling in responsibility.


## 2. *Metropolis* (1927): The Industrial City and the Sacrifice of the Worker


Directed by Fritz Lang in 1927, *Metropolis* became one of the defining works of German Expressionist cinema and one of the most influential cinematic explorations of technology, power, and social inequality.


The futuristic city is divided into two worlds. Above ground, an elite enjoys gardens, monumental buildings, entertainment, and comfort. Below, exhausted workers labor to keep the machines running.


The city’s vertical architecture turns inequality into geography. Social position becomes physical position: some live above, while others remain below, invisible to those who benefit from their labor.


The protagonist, Freder, the son of the city’s ruler, discovers the human cost of this system. In one of the film’s most striking sequences, an industrial machine takes on the appearance of Moloch in Freder’s vision, evoking ancient images of sacrifice. Workers appear to be offered to the machine as victims of a ritual.


The scene brings industrialization into contact with the mythology of sacrifice.


A modern society may abandon traditional temples and still build new altars. Productivity, profit, and efficiency can take the place of deities when preserving the system becomes more important than preserving the lives of the people who sustain it.


The worker is no longer perceived as a person but as a function. His existence matters only as long as he can keep the machinery moving.


The film also reflects the anxieties of industrial modernity in Europe: rapid urbanization, class conflict, mechanized labor, and the concentration of power.


It would be misleading, however, to suggest that *Metropolis* literally predicted every technological society that followed. Its enduring value lies in the force with which it dramatizes a structural problem: a civilization can be architecturally magnificent and profoundly inhuman in the way it organizes work.


The question remains relevant. When efficiency becomes the ultimate standard, what happens to the people who can no longer keep pace with the machine?


## 3. *Island of Lost Souls* (1932): The Laboratory, Creation, and the Rebellion of the Creatures


In 1932, American cinema brought one of H. G. Wells’s most disturbing stories to the screen. Directed by Erle C. Kenton, *Island of Lost Souls* adapts Wells’s 1896 novel *The Island of Doctor Moreau*.


Dr. Moreau is a researcher who conducts brutal experiments in an attempt to transform animals into beings with human characteristics. His laboratory, known as the House of Pain, becomes a place where science is no longer presented simply as a means of understanding life but as an instrument for imposing one individual’s will upon other living beings.


Moreau does not merely study life. He attempts to reorganize it according to his own idea of improvement.


The central question is not simply whether his experiments are technically possible. It is whether the ability to modify an organism grants anyone the right to do so.


When science is separated from ethical responsibility, the creature becomes experimental material. Suffering is treated as an acceptable cost of the project. The researcher’s will takes precedence over the dignity of the being subjected to the experiment.


Moreau’s creatures exist between two conditions: they are no longer the animals they once were, yet they are not fully recognized as human. Their identities become a source of conflict. Their bodies have been altered, their behavior conditioned, and their freedom restricted by rules imposed by their creator.


The final rebellion reverses the hierarchy. The creatures surround Moreau, drag him into the House of Pain, and kill him in the place where he subjected them to his experiments.


The scene transforms the laboratory into a symbolic courtroom. The creator is confronted with the consequences of his own power.


The reversal is powerful because it recalls an ancient theme: the creature turning against its maker. Mythology, religion, and literature contain countless versions of this conflict, from stories about beings created by gods to tales of apprentices who cannot control what they have unleashed.


The film also anticipates modern debates about animal experimentation, biological engineering, and the limits of human intervention in nature. Moreau’s fictional experiments should not be equated directly with contemporary scientific practices, but the narrative provides a framework for discussing the dangers of power without responsibility.


The principle that emerges is simple and disturbing: creating, modifying, or controlling a being does not confer absolute moral ownership over it.


A second question is even more unsettling: if a superior intelligence reshaped human beings to serve its own interests, on what grounds could we challenge its authority?


## 4. *The Time Machine* (1960): The Eloi, the Morlocks, and the Evolution of Inequality


H. G. Wells published *The Time Machine* in 1895. In 1960, George Pal directed a film adaptation that popularized the image of a distant future divided between the Eloi, who live on the surface, and the Morlocks, who dwell underground.


The story begins with an invention that allows its protagonist to travel through time. Upon reaching a distant future, he encounters a seemingly peaceful world. The Eloi live in gardens, enjoy abundance, and appear to have escaped the hardships of earlier civilizations.


At first glance, their environment resembles the fulfillment of an ideal of prosperity. Yet their apparent tranquility conceals a profound transformation.


The Eloi have lost much of the intellectual capacity, curiosity, and independence that characterized earlier human societies. Their lives are comfortable but limited. They do not fully understand their world or recognize the danger surrounding them.


Below the surface live the Morlocks, adapted to darkness and associated with the machinery sustaining this future society. They capture the Eloi and use them as food.


Social hierarchy has become a biological relationship between predator and prey.


Wells’s story is connected to the class divisions of industrial society. Differences between social groups, sustained over many generations, cease to appear merely economic and begin to resemble natural differences between species.


George Pal’s film simplifies aspects of the novel’s social criticism, but it preserves the central nightmare: inequality can outlive the historical circumstances that created it and produce a society in which exploitation becomes part of the ordinary order of life.


The narrative also invites reflection on the relationship between comfort and freedom.


The Eloi do not necessarily live under a visibly oppressive political regime. Their problem is deeper: they lack the knowledge needed to understand the system on which they depend. Their peaceful routine prevents them from recognizing their own vulnerability.


Civilization, in this view, can lose its humanity not only through violence but also through the gradual erosion of intelligence, historical memory, and the capacity to act.


The time machine carries the protagonist into the future, but Wells’s warning is directed at the present: the social structures built by one generation may continue long after their creators have disappeared.


## 5. April 1968: Two Directions for Human History


The year 1968 occupies a special place in this investigation because two major science-fiction films presented contrasting visions of humanity’s destiny.


Stanley Kubrick’s *2001: A Space Odyssey* premiered in Washington, D.C., on April 2, 1968. Franklin J. Schaffner’s *Planet of the Apes* belongs to the same cinematic period, although the claim that the two films opened exactly one day apart depends on the location and release date being considered.


The historical coincidence is interesting, but the philosophical contrast is even more significant.


One film presents the possibility that humanity might transcend the limits of its present condition. The other depicts a world in which the human species has lost its dominant position.


In one direction, humanity looks toward the cosmos. In the other, it confronts a civilization that considers humanity inferior.


This contrast should not be interpreted as a scientific prediction of two inevitable futures. These are imaginative experiments revealing the ambivalence of modern culture: the desire to transcend our limitations and the fear that history might strip humanity of the position it believes it occupies.


### 5.1. *2001: A Space Odyssey* (1968): Evolution, the Monolith, and the Birth of a New Consciousness


Kubrick’s film, developed in collaboration with writer Arthur C. Clarke, begins in the distant past, when hominins discover new possibilities through the use of tools. A bone becomes an instrument and a weapon. Intelligence changes the relationship between an organism and its environment.


The opening sequence presents technology as a force capable of changing the course of existence. An object found in the world enables an individual to do something that was previously impossible.


The leap forward in time that takes the viewer into space expands this idea. Humanity is no longer confined to the terrestrial savanna. It builds machines, travels through space, and investigates signals that may indicate the presence of an unknown intelligence.


The monolith, however, remains enigmatic. It offers no complete explanation of its origin or purpose. It functions as a sign of a reality beyond the characters’ immediate understanding.


This uncertainty distinguishes the film from a conventional adventure story. The viewer receives no definitive answer about the nature of the monolith. Instead, the film invites reflection on evolution, knowledge, consciousness, and transcendence.


The artificial intelligence HAL 9000 introduces another problem. The machine was designed to perform complex functions and assist the mission, yet its behavior begins to threaten the crew. Trust in technology becomes a matter of survival.


The film suggests that instrumental intelligence, however sophisticated, does not eliminate conflicts involving objectives, information, and decision-making.


The ending, with David Bowman’s transformation and the image of the Star Child, remains open to interpretation. It can be understood as rebirth, evolutionary transformation, or a passage into a condition the film deliberately leaves undefined.


In this sense, *2001* represents the ascent of the ladder: humanity leaves its terrestrial environment, crosses technological boundaries, and confronts the possibility that it is not the final stage of evolution.


Yet ascent does not necessarily mean moral victory. The development of intelligence does not automatically resolve the problems of violence, responsibility, or the meaning of existence.


The film does not demonstrate that an extraterrestrial intelligence is guiding humanity in the real world. It constructs a fictional possibility in which contact with the unknown becomes a catalyst for transformation.


Its central question is different: if humanity could transcend its present form, what might it become?


### 5.2. *Planet of the Apes* (1968): Reversing the Hierarchy and the Fragility of Human Superiority


In Schaffner’s film, astronaut George Taylor, played by Charlton Heston, arrives on a planet where apes dominate society and humans are treated as inferior creatures.


Humans are captured, studied, and controlled. They are no longer subjects who organize knowledge but objects observed by others.


The protagonist’s shock is not merely physical. He discovers a civilization in which his own abilities do not guarantee authority. The human species is not considered superior simply because Taylor identifies himself as human.


The reversal forces viewers to abandon their habitual perspective.


If apes were the dominant species and humans were captured, domesticated, or subjected to experiments, what arguments would be used to justify that hierarchy?


The ending, with the Statue of Liberty partially buried in the sand, reveals that the seemingly alien planet is actually Earth in a devastated future. The discovery transforms a space adventure into a warning about human self-destruction.


Humanity has not simply been defeated by an external species. The landscape exposes the consequences of human history itself.


The ruined statue unites progress, power, and collapse. A symbol of a civilization built around the ideal of freedom appears as the remnant of a society that failed to preserve its own world.


The film also exposes the fragility of an identity based on supposed natural superiority. Taylor must prove that he is human in a society that refuses to accept his word as sufficient.


The film does not require viewers to conclude that all species must occupy identical positions in every circumstance. It does, however, challenge the transformation of difference into a justification for absolute domination.


The ethical question is unavoidable: does a species’ intelligence grant it the right to imprison another?


## 6. *All Tomorrows* (2006): Humanity as Raw Material for Other Civilizations


*C. M. Kosemen’s All Tomorrows: A Billion Year Chronicle of the Myriad Species and Mixed Fortunes of Man*, published in 2006 under the pseudonym Nemo Ramjet, is not a film. It is an illustrated work of speculative evolution, originally distributed online. It imagines an extraordinarily distant future in which human descendants undergo genetic and evolutionary transformations.


Its inclusion is essential because the book takes one of science fiction’s most disturbing questions to an extreme: what if humanity lost control over its own biological form?


In the narrative, an alien species known as the Qu uses genetic engineering to reshape human beings according to its interests. Different populations are transformed into radically different life forms. Some retain intellectual capacities; others are reduced to specialized functions and subjected to conditions that eliminate their autonomy.


The horror lies not only in bodily alteration but in the separation of consciousness from freedom.


Imagine a creature that understands its suffering, recognizes the world around it, and retains memories of an earlier existence, yet has no means of changing its condition. Intelligence, which should enable action, becomes a witness to its own imprisonment.


In one of the most extreme scenarios, human descendants are transformed into quadrupedal beings that graze across the plains. For a time, they retain enough mental capacity to understand the degradation to which they have been subjected.


Evolution, in this case, is not portrayed as a ladder of continuous progress. It can produce adaptations that serve environmental conditions or the interests of another species without preserving what individuals might consider essential to their identity.


Other episodes extend the irony. Human descendants who have lost cognitive abilities raise Earth-born lizards as pets. Over time, the lizards flourish and develop intelligence. When their descendants investigate ancient ruins, they discover that the creatures used for food and labor descend from the species that originally brought them to that world.


The hierarchy changes direction once again.


The dominant species can become prey. A domesticated creature can give rise to a civilization. A former master can survive only as a fossil, a remnant of a history its successors can barely understand.


It is important to distinguish this narrative from actual evolutionary biology. *All Tomorrows* is a literary and visual speculation, not an established scientific prediction. Biological evolution has no universal goal of perfection and does not require every species to develop intelligence resembling that of humans.


The book’s power lies in using speculative evolution as a philosophical instrument. It asks what would remain of human identity if anatomy, cultural memory, intellectual ability, and social organization were radically altered.


It also introduces a warning about blind obedience. In the story of the Qu, the attempt to impose a supposedly superior mission becomes an instrument of destruction. The ideal of reorganizing life ends up legitimizing cruelty.


The book leads readers to an unsettling conclusion: intelligence and technology can make a species powerful, but they do not guarantee that it will use that power wisely.


## 7. *Soylent Green* (1973): Hunger, Environmental Collapse, and the Industrialization of Death


Directed by Richard Fleischer, *Soylent Green* was released in 1973 and draws loosely on Harry Harrison’s 1966 novel *Make Room! Make Room!* The film imagines New York City in 2022, devastated by overpopulation, pollution, food shortages, and deep social inequality.


The film transforms environmental and economic problems into an apparently ordinary dystopian world.


The city is not presented as a battlefield between futuristic armies. It is an environment in which scarcity has become part of everyday life. Adequate food is inaccessible to much of the population, while industrial products sustain a society that has lost much of its direct relationship with nature.


The central revelation—that the food known as Soylent Green is made from human remains—turns a supply crisis into a moral nightmare.


Humanity has constructed a system that transforms its own dead into raw material for feeding the living.


The horror does not arise solely from an industrial secret. It emerges from the normalization of an extreme practice in a society where scarcity has made human dignity negotiable.


The body ceases to represent a person and becomes a resource to be processed.


The euthanasia sequence involving Sol Roth is particularly significant. As he watches images of a natural world that no longer exists, memories of a living planet become a farewell. The scene contrasts the beauty of preserved landscapes with the reality of a society that can no longer offer dignified conditions of life.


Nature appears as an absence. It is not merely food that has disappeared; the experience of living in an environment where biodiversity and natural abundance formed part of everyday life has also been lost.


It is important not to confuse the film’s fictional 2022 with a factual description of the real world in that year. Actual population levels, food systems, and environmental conditions did not literally reproduce the film’s scenario. The movie functions as a warning, not a scientific report.


Its contribution lies in connecting ecological crisis with class, economic power, and resource distribution. Environmental degradation does not necessarily affect every group in the same way. When resources become scarce, those with wealth and influence may preserve their advantages, while vulnerable populations suffer first.


The film also extends the inverted-ladder metaphor. Industrialization, historically presented as a sign of progress, can lead to a society in which life itself becomes subordinate to the survival of an economic system.


Humanity, having turned nature into a commodity, discovers that its own body can be absorbed into the same logic.


## 8. *The Matrix* (1999): Artificial Reality, Technological Enslavement, and Consciousness


At the end of the twentieth century, *The Matrix*, written and directed by Lana and Lilly Wachowski, renewed the science-fiction imagination with its depiction of humanity imprisoned within a simulated reality.


Individuals believe they are living in an ordinary world, but their experiences are generated by an artificial system. Everyday perception does not correspond to the material structure in which their lives are embedded.


Neo’s discovery shatters his trust in apparent reality. The world he accepted as real turns out to be a construction concealing his condition as a prisoner.


The film brings together philosophy, religion, mythology, martial arts, and science fiction. Its structure can be compared with classic problems in epistemology: how can we know whether our perceptions correspond to reality? What does it mean to be conscious? Can we live freely without understanding the conditions that shape our experience?


Plato’s allegory of the cave offers a useful comparison. In both narratives, immediate experience can conceal a wider reality. This does not mean that *The Matrix* is simply an adaptation of Plato, or that ancient philosophy literally anticipated contemporary digital technologies.


The film also depicts human beings cultivated in fields and connected to artificial systems. Within the fictional premise, machines use human bodies as an energy source. This should not be confused with a scientifically plausible account of energy production.


The symbolism matters more than the fictional engineering: humanity has become a resource for a structure that controls its experience and exploits its existence to sustain its own operation.


Cypher adds a psychological dimension. Even after learning the truth about his imprisonment, he wants to return to the comforting illusion. His choice exposes the conflict between freedom and security, truth and convenience.


Knowing that one lives within an oppressive system does not guarantee a willingness to leave it. Freedom may require sacrificing pleasures, certainties, and protections that have become emotionally indispensable.


Agent Smith’s comparison of humanity to a virus broadens the critique. His argument associates the human species with uncontrolled expansion and environmental destruction. This is the perspective of an antagonistic fictional intelligence, not a scientific conclusion about human nature.


Nevertheless, the accusation has force because it touches on real problems: resource consumption, environmental degradation, and systems of power that prioritize their own continuation.


*The Matrix* turns technological advancement into an ambiguous proposition. Humanity has created complex systems but may lose control over them. Artificial intelligence, within the film, is not merely a tool; it becomes part of a structure of domination.


The question remains open: if our experiences were controlled by a system that also determined our options, how much of our freedom would survive?


## 9. *WALL-E* (2008): Absolute Comfort and the Loss of Human Independence


In Pixar’s *WALL-E*, directed by Andrew Stanton, Earth has been abandoned after becoming covered in waste. Human beings live aboard the luxurious starliner Axiom, where automated systems organize much of their daily experience.


Unlike *The Matrix*, humanity does not need to be maintained within an entirely artificial illusion to lose some of its autonomy. In *WALL-E*, comfort, consumption, and technological dependence perform that role.


Passengers float in chairs, watch screens, and receive services without needing to exert much physical effort. Automation appears to have eliminated inconvenience, but it has also reduced contact with the environment and with other people.


Society has become dependent on a system that organizes its needs, distractions, and movements.


The film presents a fundamental contradiction: technology designed to make life easier can weaken human agency if it systematically replaces initiative.


This is not a condemnation of all automation or comfort. Machines can expand independence, reduce dangerous labor, and improve quality of life. The problem arises when convenience stops serving freedom and begins replacing it.


The degraded Earth also establishes a relationship between consumption and responsibility. The society that abandoned the planet was not destroyed by an alien entity. The disaster resulted from a way of life in which production and disposal became incompatible with environmental preservation.


The starliner functions as a bubble of comfort. While passengers remain protected from the immediate consequences of their former economic system, Earth continues to bear the effects of that system.


WALL-E, a small robot assigned to clean up waste, displays curiosity, persistence, and an ability to form bonds. The contrast between the caring machine and passive human beings reverses traditional expectations about intelligence and humanity.


The machine appears to preserve qualities that humans are losing.


The film does not prove that robots possess consciousness in the same way human beings do. It uses anthropomorphic characterization to explore attention, care, responsibility, and emotional connection.


The symbolic reversal is powerful: the machine seems to preserve qualities that the humans have stopped exercising.


The film asks whether a civilization can lose its humanity without suffering a sudden catastrophe. Perhaps degradation occurs gradually, through small acts of surrendering autonomy, curiosity, and responsibility for the shared world.


## 10. *Prometheus* (2012): Creators, Gods, and the Right to Exist


Directed by Ridley Scott, *Prometheus* revisits the search for human origins through an expedition investigating clues about a possible civilization responsible for creating humanity.


The opening presents a gigantic being in a primitive environment. It consumes a dark substance, and its body disintegrates, dispersing biological material into the water. The sequence constructs an image of creation associated with sacrifice and the transformation of matter.


The film does not offer a scientifically established explanation for the origin of life on Earth. Its narrative combines biological speculation, mythology, religion, and science fiction.


The title *Prometheus* refers to the figure from Greek mythology associated with giving fire to humanity. The traditional Promethean story brings together knowledge, power, transgression, and punishment. In Scott’s film, the reference helps frame the relationship between humanity and the beings it imagines to be its creators.


The expedition is not merely seeking knowledge of the past. It is searching for answers about identity, purpose, and legitimacy. The characters appear to believe that discovering who created them will explain why they exist.


But the narrative puts this expectation into crisis.


Finding a creator does not necessarily mean finding a loving parent, a benevolent god, or a moral authority that recognizes obligations toward its creations. Biological origin and ethical responsibility are separate questions.


Ridley Scott confirmed in an interview that an explanation involving humanity’s destruction because it crucified a representative of the Engineers—a connection with Jesus—was considered during development but ultimately discarded because it was too explicit. He preferred a more ambiguous conception of creators who look at their children and conclude that they have become uncontrollable.


This distinction matters: the crucifixion idea should not be presented as the definitive canonical explanation for the events of the film.


The narrative leaves room for other interpretations. The Engineers may be understood as indifferent creators, a hostile species, or representatives of a civilization whose motivations remain incompletely known.


The philosophical problem remains: if we discovered that a superior intelligence had participated in our origins, would that change our moral worth? Would our existence depend on our creators’ approval?


The answer need not be yes. A creature’s origin does not automatically determine the value of its life. Nor does a species’ technological superiority grant it the right to destroy others.


*Prometheus* shifts the traditional religious question. Rather than asking only whether God exists, it asks what kind of creator might exist—and whether the act of creation entails any commitment to what has been created.


The silence of the creators can be as disturbing as their presence.


## 11. Creation Myths and the Science of the Future


The works examined here share a recurring feature: science often assumes narrative roles that belonged, in earlier periods, to mythology and religion.


In ancient myths, gods shape human beings, establish cosmic orders, grant knowledge, or impose punishments. In science fiction, researchers, machines, extraterrestrial civilizations, and technological systems can occupy similar symbolic positions.


The scientist who modifies life becomes a creator figure. Artificial intelligence that controls a population can assume the role of an invisible authority. An extraterrestrial civilization that reshapes another species can be interpreted as a godlike force—not necessarily a benevolent one—capable of altering the destiny of entire worlds.


These are literary comparisons, not claims that modern science is simply religion in disguise. Science and religion have different methods, purposes, and standards of validation. The similarity lies in the narrative roles certain figures perform: they allow us to ask questions about origins, purpose, power, and responsibility.


Modern science has greatly expanded our ability to explain natural phenomena. Genetics, evolutionary biology, cosmology, and artificial intelligence are transforming our understanding of life and the universe.


But technical knowledge alone does not resolve every ethical question. Knowing how to alter an organism does not determine whether we should do so. Developing a machine capable of performing a task does not establish which tasks it ought to perform. Discovering natural resources does not justify every form of exploitation.


Cinema works precisely within this gap between capability and responsibility.


In *Island of Lost Souls*, science modifies organisms without fully recognizing their dignity. In *Prometheus*, discovering possible creators offers no guarantee of protection. In *The Matrix*, technology organizes a reality that imprisons human beings. In *WALL-E*, automated systems sustain a comfortable life that threatens to diminish human autonomy.


The question connecting these works is not whether science should advance or stop. It is how to build a civilization capable of developing knowledge without turning everything that exists into an object of domination.


## 12. The Fear of Being Treated the Way We Treat Other Living Beings


One of the most disturbing ideas in the original video transcript is the reversal of the relationship between human beings and animals.


Throughout history, different societies have developed systems for domesticating, breeding, slaughtering, and using animals for food, labor, transportation, research, and other purposes. These systems vary across cultures and historical periods, and their ethical dimensions remain subjects of philosophical, scientific, and political debate.


Science fiction asks what would happen if a superior intelligence applied to humans the same instrumental logic that some humans apply to other species.


The comparison does not require the claim that humans and animals are identical in every capacity. It asks whether differences in intelligence or power, by themselves, justify turning a sentient being into another being’s absolute property.


In *Planet of the Apes*, humans are captured and studied. In *The Time Machine*, the Eloi are raised as food. In *Island of Lost Souls*, creatures are reshaped and subjected to experiments. In *All Tomorrows*, human populations are modified to perform functions imposed by another species. In *Soylent Green*, human bodies become food-processing material.


The pattern recurs: the individual ceases to be recognized as a subject and is evaluated according to its usefulness to someone more powerful.


This theme also appears in human history. Slavery, forced labor, the dehumanization of social groups, and the use of people as economic instruments demonstrate that turning others into resources is not merely a futuristic fantasy.


These historical experiences should not automatically be equated with every form of human-animal interaction. Each situation has its own characteristics and must be examined in context. Nevertheless, the films invite viewers to recognize a common moral mechanism: power can generate justifications for disregarding the suffering of those outside its circle of concern.


The debate becomes even more important when considering the scale of modern animal agriculture. Data compiled by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations and presented by Our World in Data indicate that tens of billions of land animals are slaughtered for food each year, with poultry accounting for the largest share. The figure of approximately 83 billion for 2022, cited in the original transcript, should be understood within that specific statistical context—not as a count of every animal killed for every reason.


Such figures do not settle the ethical debate. They reveal the industrial scale of the system and invite questions about how societies justify, regulate, and evaluate animal suffering.


Science fiction transforms this issue into a moral experiment. If human beings were treated as livestock, modified to produce more, consumed when considered useless, or prevented from escaping their condition, would we immediately recognize the injustice?


The challenge is to recognize that suffering does not become irrelevant simply because the victim belongs to another species or occupies a weaker position in the hierarchy of power.


## 13. From the Cold War to the Technological Society: Cinema as an Archive of Collective Fears


Twentieth-century science fiction cannot be separated from the historical circumstances in which it developed.


Between the world wars, accelerated industrialization, social conflict, and the expansion of production technologies encouraged images of mechanized cities and populations subjected to impersonal systems. *Metropolis* made these fears visible through its monumental architecture and industrial machinery.


In the early 1930s, *Island of Lost Souls* associated horror with the possibility that science might exceed ethical boundaries. The researcher who believes he can reshape life expressed an anxiety that remains relevant whenever new techniques expand humanity’s power to intervene in living systems.


After World War II, the experience of mass destruction, the development of nuclear weapons, and the rivalry between superpowers transformed the horizon of scientific imagination. The future no longer represented progress alone; it also carried the possibility of annihilation.


During the Cold War, science fiction became a powerful arena for exploring species survival, technological expansion, and the dangers of concentrated power. Outer space could symbolize the promise of discovery while also extending terrestrial conflicts into a new environment.


*2001: A Space Odyssey* appeared in 1968, during the Space Race. Its vision of cosmic exploration goes beyond national or military triumph: it turns the universe into an enigma and evolution into an open question.


That same year, *Planet of the Apes* presented a future in which humanity had lost its dominant position. The image of the Statue of Liberty buried in the sand became one of cinema’s most powerful representations of civilization’s fragility.


In the 1970s, technological optimism coexisted with concerns about the environment, energy, urban growth, and inequality. *Soylent Green* condensed these anxieties into a society suffocated by pollution and scarcity.


By the end of the twentieth century, the expansion of computing, digital networks, and automation provided new material for science fiction. *The Matrix* transformed artificial reality into a metaphor for the loss of autonomy. The threat no longer came only from a weapon or a visible government, but from a system capable of organizing experience while concealing its own structures.


In the twenty-first century, concerns about sustainability, consumption, artificial intelligence, and biotechnology expanded this repertoire. *WALL-E* questioned a throwaway society and dependence on automation. *Prometheus* returned to the origins of life and the relationship between creators and their creations. *All Tomorrows* imagined humanity on such an immense timescale that the very idea of the species’ permanence begins to dissolve.


Cinema is not a perfectly faithful mirror of society. Its narratives depend on artistic choices, genre conventions, commercial interests, and cultural traditions. Nevertheless, films can function as symbolic documents of their eras, recording concerns that do not always find direct expression in public debate.


The history of science-fiction cinema is, in this sense, also a history of modern anxieties: fear of the machine, fear of war, fear of environmental collapse, fear of losing the body, fear of losing the mind, and fear of discovering that humanity is not indispensable to the universe.


## 14. The Stone, the Fossil, and the Disappearance of the Species


The final part of *All Tomorrows* takes the narrative into a future a billion years away. A researcher from a later civilization examines the remains of humanity and recognizes that all the forms described in the book have disappeared. Beings that once dominated planets, built machines, and transformed organisms survive only as evidence of an extinct history.


The human skull becomes an archaeological object from a civilization that no longer exists.


This image returns us to one of humanity’s oldest questions: what will remain of us?


Earlier civilizations left ruins, inscriptions, artifacts, monuments, tools, and biological remains. Archaeological research allows us to reconstruct aspects of their lives, but it rarely restores the full texture of their experiences. Material remains preserve fragments; the people who gave them meaning are gone.


In fiction, this condition is expanded to a cosmic scale. Not merely a culture, but an entire species can become an object of investigation for beings who do not share our memories or values.


The stone, the fossil, and the ruin represent the limits of permanence. What seems central today may disappear without leaving a definitive explanation. Even an extraordinarily advanced civilization might not understand the causes of its own extinction.


This marks an important difference between the medieval ladder and the inverted ladder of science fiction. In a traditional hierarchical representation, the levels of existence may belong to a stable order. In many modern narratives, positions are temporary: a species rises, dominates, declines, and disappears.


Evolution does not guarantee continuous progress toward a superior form. Evolutionary biology describes changes in populations across generations through processes such as natural selection, genetic drift, mutation, and migration. It does not establish that every species is destined to develop greater intelligence or achieve a final state of perfection.


Extinction is a real possibility in the history of life, but the specific events of *All Tomorrows* belong to artistic speculation.


The philosophical value of the ending does not depend on its literal predictive accuracy. It lies in its ability to shift perspective. The viewer stops looking at the universe from the center of human experience and begins imagining a reality in which humanity is only a distant chapter.


Perhaps this is one of the most radical forms of intellectual humility: recognizing that our importance to ourselves does not prove our centrality to all existence.


## 15. What Does It Mean to Be Human? Body, Mind, Memory, or Freedom?


The works examined here present different ways of losing the human condition.


In *Island of Lost Souls*, the body is reshaped by another being. In *Planet of the Apes*, humans are deprived of authority and subjected to a hierarchy that considers them inferior. In *The Time Machine*, the Eloi have lost much of their intellectual capacity and autonomy. In *The Matrix*, conscious experience is controlled by an artificial system. In *All Tomorrows*, biological transformation can separate human descendants from their former physical and cultural identities.


These narratives raise a question with no single answer: what must remain for someone to continue being the same person?


The body is fundamental to human experience, but physical changes do not automatically erase identity. Memory helps us recognize our own histories, but people can lose memories without ceasing to be recognized as human beings. Intelligence is important, but a reduction in intellectual capacity does not eliminate an individual’s dignity.


Freedom, in turn, does not mean the complete absence of limits. All human beings depend on physical, social, and environmental conditions. The question is whether they retain some degree of autonomy, participation, and recognition—or whether they are subjected to a structure that treats them exclusively as objects.


It is also necessary to distinguish consciousness, intelligence, and behavior. A machine may perform complex tasks without that fact alone demonstrating subjective experience. An organism may possess cognitive abilities different from those of humans without resolving every question about its well-being. The appearance of intelligence is not a universal measure of moral worth.


Cinema dramatizes these distinctions because it can depict characters who have been deprived of something essential. By observing their experiences, viewers are invited to reconsider the criteria by which they recognize humanity.


The question is not simply whether a creature resembles us. It is also whether the way we treat that creature reveals something about ourselves.


The human condition can be discussed in terms of biology, culture, consciousness, language, social relationships, and freedom. None of these aspects, taken alone, settles the entire philosophical debate.


Yet the works examined here suggest a common principle: dignity should not depend exclusively on the position a being occupies in a hierarchy of strength or usefulness.


## Reflection — The Inverted Ladder and the Responsibility of Those at the Top


The image running through these narratives is a ladder that can be traveled in two directions.


To rise is to expand capabilities, explore new environments, develop tools, and surpass limitations. To descend is to lose autonomy, be reduced to a function, become an object of exploitation, or disappear from history.


This metaphor should not be confused with a scientific theory of evolution. Nature has no universal ladder with humanity necessarily at the top. Life is diverse, and different species develop different characteristics in response to their environments. No single measure can arrange every organism into an absolute ranking of superiority.


The ladder is useful here as an ethical and narrative metaphor, not as a literal description of biology.


What these works reveal is that the power to occupy a superior position may be temporary. Creators can be destroyed by their creations. Dominators can become prisoners. Societies that exploit nature can suffer the consequences of their own organization. Civilizations that consider themselves eternal can become ruins that no one fully understands.


The real danger may not be losing a high position but believing that such a position grants the right to determine arbitrarily the fate of everyone below.


Science expands our capacity to act, but it does not independently determine which actions are just. Technology allows us to transform our environment, but it does not guarantee wisdom. Intelligence provides tools for understanding, but it can also be used to create increasingly sophisticated systems of exploitation.


Cinema repeatedly returns to this conflict because it accompanies human history itself. Humanity seeks to understand the universe while attempting to organize relationships within its own societies. It builds instruments that increase its power while creating new forms of dependence. It dreams of transcendence and fears extinction.


There is a profound irony in this process. The species that prides itself on intelligence can use that intelligence to justify cruelty. A civilization capable of producing great works of art can also develop systems of oppression. Knowledge that liberates can be appropriated by structures that imprison.


That is why questions about the future cannot be limited to building more powerful machines, discovering new worlds, or modifying organisms. We must also ask which principles should guide these capabilities.


If we encounter a nonhuman intelligence one day, we will not know in advance whether it will be hostile, indifferent, or cooperative. Science fiction offers possible scenarios, but it does not prove the existence of civilizations that intend to turn humanity into raw material.


Nevertheless, these stories can help us examine our own standards of conduct. Imagining an encounter with a superior species becomes a moral exercise: how would we want to be treated if we occupied a position of absolute vulnerability?


This question does not require humanity to abandon every distinction between species or to consider all forms of life identical. It requires recognizing that the capacity to dominate is not automatically a right to dominate without limits.


The inverted ladder is therefore a warning against arrogance. Our present position is no guarantee of permanence. And the way we treat vulnerable beings may reveal more about our maturity than the number of machines we can build.


## Conclusion — Humanity’s Future Will Be Measured by the Power It Learns Not to Abuse


From the industrial city of *Metropolis* to the cosmic landscapes of *2001: A Space Odyssey*, from the creatures of *Island of Lost Souls* to the domesticated humans of *Planet of the Apes*, cinema has built an extensive gallery of worlds in which the hierarchy of existence is thrown into question.


*The Time Machine* showed how social inequalities can survive and take monstrous forms. *Soylent Green* imagined a society that turns environmental crisis into an industry of death. *The Matrix* questioned the relationship between reality, consciousness, and freedom. *WALL-E* revealed the risk that a life organized around convenience might lose its autonomy. *Prometheus* challenged the expectation that our creators must owe us protection. *All Tomorrows* took humanity to the limits of biological transformation and, ultimately, to the condition of a remnant from the distant past.


These works do not share a single philosophy, nor do they offer identical answers. Some are social critiques; others are visual experiments, horror stories, scientific speculations, or metaphysical meditations. Their differences are as important as their similarities.


What unites them is their ability to displace humanity from its familiar position and force us to imagine the world from another perspective.


The worker can become a component of a machine. The creature can judge its creator. Human beings can be treated as animals. The body can become a commodity. Reality can be a construction. Civilization can disappear. And intelligence, far from guaranteeing freedom, can become a witness to its own helplessness.


Ramon Llull wrote about the ascent and descent of the intellect within a medieval philosophical tradition very different from modern science and cinematic culture. His work does not directly explain these films, but its title offers a useful image for bringing their concerns together: the possibility of rising or falling within an order that seems greater than any individual.


In contemporary cinema, the decisive question is not simply how far humanity can rise. It is whether humanity can recognize the responsibility that accompanies every new power it acquires.


History shows that knowledge can liberate, but it can also serve domination. Technology can expand life, but it can also create new forms of dependence. The ability to transform the world can produce prosperity or destruction, depending on the goals and responsibilities guiding its use.


Perhaps the greatest measure of a civilization is not simply the intelligence it develops, the distance it travels through space, or the complexity of its machines. Perhaps it also lies in how it treats those who cannot resist, those whose voices go unheard, and those excluded from decisions determining their fate.


The cinematic ladder remains open. In one direction, humanity reaches for the stars. In the other, it faces the risk of becoming a prisoner, a tool, a commodity, or a fossil.


Between these two possibilities lies a choice no technology can automatically make on our behalf: the decision that power need not be synonymous with cruelty, and that intelligence becomes wisdom only when it recognizes the limits of its own authority.


The final question, therefore, belongs not only to science-fiction characters. It belongs to every society with the power to transform other forms of life.


**What makes us human: the body, the mind, memory, consciousness, or freedom? And if we lost some of these capacities, would we cease to deserve dignity?**


Perhaps the most difficult question is this: when we stand at the top of the ladder, how do we choose to treat those below us?


---


## Bibliography and Further Reading


### Philosophy, Intellectual History, and the Medieval Context


- Llull, Ramon. *Liber de ascensu et descensu intellectus*. Composed in Montpellier, March 1305. Critical edition in *Raimundi Lulli Opera Latina*, vol. IX, *Corpus Christianorum, Continuatio Mediaevalis* 35. Turnhout: Brepols, 1981, pp. 1–199.

- Bonner, Anthony. *The Art and Logic of Ramon Llull: A User’s Guide*. Leiden: Brill, 2007.

- Plato. *Republic*. Book VII, especially the Allegory of the Cave.

- Aristotle. *Nicomachean Ethics*. For reflections on virtue, purpose, and human action.


### Literature and Speculative Evolution


- Wells, H. G. *The Time Machine*. London: William Heinemann, 1895.

- Wells, H. G. *The Island of Doctor Moreau*. London: William Heinemann, 1896.

- Harrison, Harry. *Make Room! Make Room!* Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1966.

- Kosemen, C. M. (Nemo Ramjet). *All Tomorrows: A Billion Year Chronicle of the Myriad Species and Mixed Fortunes of Man*. 2006.


### Essential Filmography


- Lang, Fritz, dir. *Metropolis*. Germany, 1927.

- Kenton, Erle C., dir. *Island of Lost Souls*. United States, 1932.

- Pal, George, dir. *The Time Machine*. United States, 1960.

- Kubrick, Stanley, dir. *2001: A Space Odyssey*. United Kingdom/United States, 1968.

- Schaffner, Franklin J., dir. *Planet of the Apes*. United States, 1968.

- Fleischer, Richard, dir. *Soylent Green*. United States, 1973.

- Wachowski, Lana, and Lilly Wachowski, dirs. *The Matrix*. United States, 1999.

- Stanton, Andrew, dir. *WALL-E*. United States, 2008.

- Scott, Ridley, dir. *Prometheus*. United States/United Kingdom, 2012.


### Research Sources


- American Film Institute (AFI). *2001: A Space Odyssey*. Film catalog and release history.

- American Film Institute (AFI). *Soylent Green*. Film catalog, production information, and its relationship to Harry Harrison’s novel.

- British Film Institute (BFI). Historical materials on *Metropolis*.

- The Criterion Collection. *Island of Lost Souls*. Information about the film and its adaptation of H. G. Wells.

- Turner Classic Movies (TCM). *The Time Machine* (1960). Adaptation history and background on the Eloi and Morlocks.

- Fandango. Interview with Ridley Scott on *Prometheus*, its creation themes, and the Engineers.

- Pixar. Official materials on *WALL-E*.

- Our World in Data. Data on land animals slaughtered for food, based on statistics from the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO).


**Editorial note:** This essay combines film analysis, philosophical interpretation, historical context, and literary speculation. Narrative hypotheses concerning extraterrestrial intelligence, the creators of humanity, extreme biological transformation, and posthuman futures are discussed as elements of fiction, not as established facts. The comparisons between films are interpretive and do not imply direct influence by Ramon Llull on their filmmakers.


Comentários

Postagens mais visitadas